esurance.com
esurance.com
Get leads like Esurance — and thousands more
Build targeted lists by tech stack, traffic, and more
Esurance: The Digital Insurance Pioneer That Lost Its Edge
How a $389M revenue company with 2M+ monthly visits is losing the direct-to-consumer battle
Esurance was the first major insurance brand built entirely for the digital age, but its 1.3-star Trustpilot rating reveals a stark reality: digital convenience doesn't guarantee customer satisfaction. With $389.5M in revenue and 172K monthly visits, Esurance represents both the promise and peril of insurtech disruption.
"Esurance proves that being 'digital-first' isn't enough when traditional insurers like GEICO and Progressive have caught up—and surpassed you on customer experience."
The Traffic Paradox
Despite 56% direct traffic and 41% organic search, Esurance's 172K monthly visits pale compared to competitors. The brand commands 20.5K searches for 'esurance' monthly, yet gets outpaced by generic 'car insurance' queries (294K volume). This suggests strong brand recognition but weak conversion funnel performance. The real red flag? Their top keyword after branded terms is 'esurance login'—not 'esurance quote'—indicating existing customers struggle more than prospects engage.
The Trust Crisis
With only 62 Trustpilot reviews and a catastrophic 1.3-star rating, Esurance faces a reputation crisis that no amount of SEO can fix. For a company with 2,140 employees serving $389.5M in revenue, this represents roughly $181K revenue per employee—efficient on paper, but the customer experience metrics suggest unsustainable churn. The 88,735 backlinks indicate strong historical SEO authority, but modern consumers trust peer reviews over backlink profiles.
The executive team—led by CEO Gary Tolman and CIO Elinor MacKinnon—built a tech-forward insurance platform before 'insurtech' was a buzzword. Yet their current position reveals a classic innovator's dilemma: they disrupted traditional insurers but failed to maintain their digital edge as competitors like Lemonade and Root emerged. The company's structure, with dedicated directors for Claims (Mike Magee) and Financial Planning (Sarah Cohen), suggests operational maturity, but the 1.3-star rating indicates execution gaps in customer-facing processes.
- Brand recognition is strong (20.5K monthly searches) but conversion is weak
- Trustpilot rating of 1.3/5 signals severe customer satisfaction issues
- 56% direct traffic shows brand awareness, but 41% organic suggests over-reliance on search
- Top keywords reveal more login friction than acquisition success
The Digital Insurance Pioneer That Lost Its Way
Esurance's $389M revenue and 172K monthly visits mask a deeper problem: in the race to digitize insurance, being first doesn't mean being best. The 1.3-star rating and login-focused keyword strategy suggest a company optimizing for retention over experience—a fatal flaw in an industry where switching costs are low and trust is everything.
How much traffic does Esurance get?
Traffic & Engagement
Rankings
Backlinks & Authority
Search Traffic
Top Organic Keywords
Where is Esurance's audience located?
Who competes with Esurance?
Device Distribution
What keywords does Esurance rank for?
5 keywordsWhat is Esurance's revenue?
Who works at Esurance?
Loading leads...
What do customers think of Esurance?
Esurance
Categories
Activity & Engagement
Contact Information
Reviews (20)
Unsure what to feel about Esurance, but likely won't re-enroll.
I had been with Esurance for about four years before I moved out of my state of Florida. For the most part it had been okay: I am a very low-risk driver so I never get into accidents, therefore I never had to deal with the insurance folks. They also offered the most competitive rate. But after my vehicle was sideswiped in summer 2023 by a speeding driver, who admitted fault on the spot, my insurance fee went up by a hundred dollars (I pay on biannual basis). This is something perhaps many auto insurance companies are guilty of. Then when I moved out of Florida to abroad for work, I spoke with an agent to cancel my auto insurance as my vehicle would not be in operation for most of the year. I am not sure if I made it clear that the cancellation was temporary--I thought I did, but I was not advised to keep the insurance on. Because a month later (last week or so), I learned that Florida DMV sent me a letter saying that Esurance let them know I canceled my policy, and the DMV requests me to reinstate an auto insurance or my license gets suspended. This would be very bad, since I have to move back to Florida later this year. Up until when I learned of the letter I was not aware that Florida law requires you to have an auto insurance at all time if you want to keep your Florida license and vehicle registration. It complicated matters as I was already abroad at the time... While my own ignorance is one thing, I just think it is strange that the Esurance agent who spoke with me over the phone did not let me know of this--the only reasonable excuse would be maybe I did not make it clear my move was temporary, but I thought I told them that I plan to still use them when I am back later this year, so to me it would make sense then that they advise me to keep the insurance.
Terrible customer service designed to avoid paying what they owe and wasting your time.
Road side assistance always says they can’t see your coverage and that you’ll have to pay out of pocket and request reimbursement which will be near impossible to receive as you will have to spend hours waiting on hold and obtaining and emailing receipts and then following up repeatedly. This happened to me twice, same inconvenient process.
Crooks, Pure and Simple
Esurance is yet another fraudulent company that not only offers nothing, but when you end your contract, they simply continue to take money out of your account. They stole over $700 from me, even when I no longer had a car. Yes, I know what you're thinking. “Get a Lawyer,” right? And yes, that’s good advice, but they have an army of lawyers, and in the end, it's their word against yours. I fail to understand why and how these fake companies can keep robbing people with no legal interception from anyone. One would think the Federal Trade Commission would look into it, but they don’t, and they don’t care either. Pathetic. At any rate, Esurance would not cover a simple thermostat, which is a part of the engine. The engine is the first thing covered in their program, and more so in their coverage, which I had. But, as any attorney worth their salt will tell you, “READ THE CONTRACT AND EVERY ADDENDUM THEREIN.” I did not read the fine details, which, by the way, are so small you need an electron microscope to read them. So, in the end, I was screwed yet again. EXAMPLE: Let’s say you’re covered for the air conditioning in your car. Okay, fine. The mechanic calls Esurance, and a claim is issued. But wait! They only cover the fuses in your air conditioner, and not the repair of the air conditioner itself. Oh, so sorry…you get ‘DECLINED.’ But of course, the worst part is that they kept withdrawing money from my account even when my car was totaled, and I ended the service with them. In my mind, this should be illegal…but not today. Not in America. BEWARE…BEWARE…BEWARE! Based on the provided search results, there have been several lawsuits filed against Esurance regarding their insurance practices, but these are primarily related to general auto insurance policies and claims, not specifically about Esurance vehicle service contracts or extended warranties. Examples of Lawsuits Against Esurance: • Class action regarding sales tax on totaled vehicles: A policyholder filed a class-action lawsuit claiming Esurance and its claims administrator failed to cover sales tax on totaled vehicles, despite policy terms. • PIP benefit termination during medical treatment: A proposed class action alleged Esurance improperly ended Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits once a policyholder was deemed to have reached "maximum medical improvement". • Underinsured motorist (UIM) claims and bad faith: A case involved a UIM claim where the plaintiffs contended Esurance failed to adequately investigate and make a reasonable offer, violating insurance regulations and acting in bad faith. • Collision coverage claims: A case from 2017 involved a dispute over a collision coverage claim, with the plaintiff alleging breach of contract and bad faith on the part of Esurance. Regarding Vehicle Service Contracts/Extended Warranties: • There's a mentioned class action lawsuit against Endurance Warranty Services, a third-party provider of Vehicle Service Contracts, which alleges delayed claim processing and unjustified denials of coverage. This lawsuit is not related to Esurance. Just don’t do it! They’re all crooks!
Can't make a payment
Can't make a payment, WTF? I have a new card and just want to pay my monthly payment, but I have tried on 3 different devices on three different internet connections and their website is so messed up it won't let me. I called to make a payment but their offices are located in flippin' Africa...I'm not doing that, has esurance lost their minds???
I wasn't at fault so why treat me like I am
I had an accident. The other drive ran the red light. It was documented on the police report. They still want me to pay my deductible instead of going after the other person's insurance. They also refuse to speak with me. When I call I am transferred numerous times then hung up on and emails are never returned.
Frequently Asked Questions about Esurance
What is Esurance's Revenue?
How fast is Esurance growing?
How do people interact with Esurance?
How do people find Esurance?
Who uses Esurance?
Who are Esurance's competitors?
What do customers think of Esurance?
Export Data
Unlock all exports
Download CSVs, JSONs & full reports
Export esurance.com Data
Download the complete tech stack, analytics, leads, and company data for esurance.com in JSON or CSV format. Use it for your sales pipeline, competitive analysis, or research.
Raw JSON Data
Click "Show" to view the raw API response data
About esurance.com
Company Overview
Traffic & Audience
esurance.com receives approximately 172.5K monthly visitors and ranks #190,963 globally. The website has a bounce rate of 34% with visitors viewing an average of 4.4 pages per visit. Users spend an average of 2:41 on the site.
The majority of esurance.com's traffic comes from undefined, undefined, .
Frequently Asked Questions
What is esurance.com?
How popular is esurance.com?
Related Searches
This page provides publicly available information about esurance.com. Data is collected from various public sources and may not always be up to date. For the most accurate information, please visit esurance.com directly at https://esurance.com.